Reflexivity from Hierarchical Causality

Tim Gebbie

Complex systems are often organised into hierarchies whose internal interactions are stronger or faster than interactions across levels. When markets are treated as genuinely multilevel systems it becomes natural to represent them as systems with hierarchical causality. Here we show that reflexivity can be formulated within such a discrete hierarchical causal system; but one in which a higher-level actor state restricts the lower-level transition kernels that remain admissible. Then event dynamics can be separated from calendar embeddings: a set-valued actor-conditioned correspondence can be used to define the admissible family of event kernels, while joint state and waiting-time laws can be used to determine compatible timing to then natural demonstrate reflexivity. A selected event-state law need not determine a unique calendar embedding. Locally, uniqueness of the joint event or timing specification requires uniqueness of both the admissible event kernel and its compatible timing law. Reflexivity is thus the endogenous closure of a hierarchical constraint loop, while timing and projection can generate calendar-time memory or causal ambiguity even for Markov event dynamics.

Read the full article at: arxiv.org

Kingmaking: How Venture Capitalists Pick Artificial Intelligence Winners

Marta Zava

Training a frontier artificial intelligence model costs hundreds of millions of dollars before a product exists, and few investors can write that cheque. This paper shows that the number who can falls as the fixed cost of a first training run rises, at a rate set by the concentration of the fund size distribution, so that doubling the cost removes about two thirds of the possible backers. The firms that compete are therefore selected by a small group of allocators before any customer has expressed a view. Three results follow. The price paid by the winner separates into a rational bid, a premium created by the fund’s deployment clock, and an error from failing to adjust for adverse selection, and the sign of the price response to competition identifies which one dominates. Concentration trades breadth for depth, improving the funded set only when the skill advantage of the few outweighs the information lost through having fewer independent views, a loss that is small when investors think alike. And large upfront cheques reduce the value of stopping, so ventures funded under deployment pressure should fail later and larger rather than more often. The effective policy margin is access to compute rather than regulation of the capital market.Training a frontier artificial intelligence model costs hundreds of millions of dollars before a product exists, and few investors can write that cheque. This paper shows that the number who can falls as the fixed cost of a first training run rises, at a rate set by the concentration of the fund size distribution, so that doubling the cost removes about two thirds of the possible backers. The firms that compete are therefore selected by a small group of allocators before any customer has expressed a view. Three results follow. The price paid by the winner separates into a rational bid, a premium created by the fund’s deployment clock, and an error from failing to adjust for adverse selection, and the sign of the price response to competition identifies which one dominates. Concentration trades breadth for depth, improving the funded set only when the skill advantage of the few outweighs the information lost through having fewer independent views, a loss that is small when investors think alike. And large upfront cheques reduce the value of stopping, so ventures funded under deployment pressure should fail later and larger rather than more often. The effective policy margin is access to compute rather than regulation of the capital market.

Read the full article at: papers.ssrn.com

Beyond Black Swans: Inhabiting Indeterminacy by Piero Dominici

This book describes the urgent need of modern humanity to renew and reinforce an open attitude to the complexity of life, above all by embracing its intrinsic indeterminacy, rather than attempting futilely to control its evolution. Oblivious to this ever-more urgent necessity, seduced by the speed and virality of digital pattern recognition, computing, and artificial simulation of human thought, society has reverted to a linear, deterministic concept of reality, under the belief that everything can be measured and managed, and that error and unpredictability will soon be eliminated from our lives and organizations. Consequently, choices and responsibilities have been delegated to technology, artificial intelligence and algorithms, even in educational institutions, which are now preoccupied with teaching mere skills and know-how, thus committing the fatal error of confusing artificial, mechanical, complicated systems with living, complex, adaptive systems. 

This volume is intended not only for complexity/social scientists, philosophers and students, but to the curious from all walks of life. It calls for learning to inhabit complexity, while recognizing and participating in its interdependent, interconnected, interactive systems of relationships. Dominici reveals the futility of endeavoring to control the uncontrollable or observe the unobservable, showing how self-organization and emergence, triggered from the smallest and most modest elements, impact the entire system.

More at: link.springer.com

Embedding of low-dimensional sensory dynamics in recurrent networks: Implications for the geometry of neural representation

Vikas N. O’Reilly-Shah & Alessandro Maria Selvitella 

Journal of Computational Neuroscience

Neural population activity in sensory cortex is organized on low-dimensional manifolds, but it is unclear why such manifolds should arise and what determines their geometry. We address this sensory representation problem by modeling cortical populations as recurrent circuits driven by low-dimensional, regular sensory dynamics (e.g. motion on a circle, head direction, multi-frequency tones on tori). By combining tools from generalized synchronization and delay-embedding theory, specialized to this quasiperiodic regime, we show that contracting recurrent networks generically develop smooth internal manifolds that embed the sensory dynamics. The dimensional requirement is modest and depends only on the intrinsic dimension $$\varvec{d}$$ of the effective sensory manifold, not on the complexity of the external world: a hidden dimension $$\varvec{N>2d}$$ generically suffices (e.g. $$\varvec{N\ge 3}$$ for a circle, $$\varvec{N\ge 5}$$ for a two-frequency torus; bounds compatible with Whitney and Takens’ embedding theorems). We then prove a prediction–separation result that links representational geometry directly to predictive performance, without assuming knowledge of contraction rates: if the circuit can predict future sensory inputs with small error, then states with different futures must be separated in neural state space, up to a resolution set by the prediction error. The resulting scale-limited embeddings naturally give rise to categorical boundaries, metameric equivalence of distinct stimuli, and discrimination thresholds. Numerical experiments with trained $$\varvec{\tanh }$$ recurrent networks driven by head-direction-like and multi-frequency signals recover ring- and torus-shaped hidden manifolds with the expected topology; state separation improves most rapidly near the $$\varvec{2d+1}$$ threshold. Training typically pushes the networks beyond the strict contraction regime where the theory guarantees faithful embedding, yet convergence consistent with generalized synchronization and manifold recovery persist, indicating that our conditions are sufficient but not necessary. Together, these results provide a mechanistic account of why low-dimensional sensory manifolds emerge in recurrent circuits and how prediction constrains their resolution, grounded in dynamical systems embedding theory and consistent with empirical findings on cortical population dynamics.

Read the full article at: link.springer.com

ALIFE 2027: The Artificial Life Conference. Prague, Czech Republic, July 19-23

The conference will bring together researchers, artists, educators, and practitioners exploring the science, technology, and creativity of Artificial Life.

Organized by the University of Chemistry and Technology Prague and Czech Technical University.

More at: alife.vscht.cz