John Stewart

An acceptable information-processing theory of consciousness should be able to identify the adaptive advantages that drove the emergence of consciousness during the evolution of life. It should also predict the specific dynamical architecture of information processing that would need to be instantiated in AI to produce consciousness and the superior adaptation it enables. Whether such an instantiation produces AI that is actually conscious and also more adaptable would provide the ultimate test of the theory. A prime candidate for such a theory is the Subject-Object Emergence Theory of consciousness. It argues that consciousness first evolved because it enabled organisms to achieve adaptive body-environment coordination without extensive trial-and-error learning. It postulates that the subject in an appropriate Subject-Object subsystem would be able to use depictive (iconic) visual representations of the relative positions of its body and the environment to guide motor actions that will produce adaptive body-environment coordination. The depictive representations will ‘light up’ for such a subject, producing subjective experience that is used to deliver adaptive benefits. Hand-eye coordination is a familiar example in humans-novel and intricate coordination tasks can be undertaken without additional reinforcement learning, provided focused conscious attention is employed to provide us (the subject) with relevant depictive images. The paper identifies how such a conscious Subject-Object subsystem could be instantiated in AI systems, enabling hand-eye and other body-environment coordination without the extensive reinforcement learning or complex computational programming needed at present. Drawing further on the Subject-Object theory of consciousness, the paper also identifies how these simple conscious subsystems evolved further in organisms to establish the conscious modelling that enables conscious planning, imagining, abduction and other higher cognitive functions. It demonstrates that current approaches to incorporating world modelling in AI will fail to achieve key elements of the general intelligence found in humans that require consciousness.

Read the full article at: papers.ssrn.com

Ryosuke Takata, Yujin Tang, Yingtao Tian, Norihiro Maruyama, Hiroki Kojima, Takashi Ikegami,

Collective Intelligence

This study simulates the dynamics of a collection of clonal agents responding to chemical gradients (chemotaxis) to demonstrate the evolution of individual variation. To build our multi-agent simulation, we first optimized single agents that rely on a neural network to perform chemotaxis. We then constructed multi-agent simulations using clones of these evolved individuals. We find that mutual interactions lead to the emergence of behavioral variation. We also find population-level performance degradation during later evolutionary stages, despite maintained high individual performance and simplified neural architectures. This decline occurred because agents developed reduced sensory-motor coupling. This latter finding demonstrates that incentives for individual variation worked against the collective interest.

Read the full article at: journals.sagepub.com